publications full of ideas

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals Creates New Risks for Employers with Gender Pay Disparities

5.7.2018

A recent Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals opinion upended long-standing precedent under which employers could rely on prior salary data to justify pay differences between employees of different genders when defending claims under the Equal Pay Act of 1963 (EPA). The EPA prohibits paying different amounts to male and female employees for doing equal work except when made pursuant to a seniority system, a merit system, a system which measures earnings by quantity or quality of production, or for “a differential based on any other factor other than sex.”

In Rizo v. Yovino, 2018 U.S. App. LEXIS 8882 (9th Cir. Apr. 9, 2018), the Ninth Circuit analyzed whether pay differentials based on prior salary history were an exception to the EPA prohibitions because they are based on a “factor other than sex.” The court decided they were not, holding that prior salary cannot justify gender-based pay differences when the employees are performing equal work. In short, Rizo learned some of her male colleagues who were hired after she was earned higher salaries. Her employer did not dispute this, but argued it was permissible because it set the starting salaries based on what its employees had earned at their previous jobs. In this case, that resulted in Rizo being paid less than men with similar skills and experience.

Overruling Kouba v. Allstate Ins. Co., 691 F.2d 873 (9th Cir. 1982), the court held an employee’s prior salary does not constitute a “factor other than sex” upon which a wage differential may be based. The court said “any other factor other than sex” is limited to legitimate, job-related factors such as a prospective employee’s experience, educational background, ability, or prior job performance.

Although some states and municipalities (not North Carolina and none in North Carolina) have recently passed laws prohibiting gender based pay differences based on prior salary history, Rizo marks a major change in interpreting the EPA, and creates new risks for employers. Many employers likely rely on prior pay history to justify current pay differentials, and that reliance may expose them to significant liability. Although the Ninth Circuit does not cover North Carolina, it would not be surprising to see other Circuit Courts rely on Rizo to make similar rulings. At a minimum, plaintiffs may be emboldened to bring EPA claims against employers arguing Rizo entitles them to relief where none was previously available. Prudent employers should audit their employees’ pay to determine if gender disparity exists, and if so, either close the disparity or identify an exception to the EPA other than prior salary history to justify the disparity.

Physical Address: 301 Fayetteville Street, Suite 1900, Raleigh, NC 27601 | © Poyner Spruill LLP. All rights reserved.

related information

what's new at the firm

Poyner Spruill names new partner, welcomes three new attorneys to strengthen North Carolina practice

1/16/2019

RALEIGH, N.C. — Poyner Spruill LLP, a commercial law firm with offices across North Carolina, is pleased to announce the firm has named Emily Meeker a partner of the firm while also welcoming three new attorneys, one of whom is returning after serving in an in-house counsel role with a healthcare company.

Our Voices - Cultivating Leadership: An Intimate Discussion with Leaders in our Communities

1/14/2019

The Poyner Spruill Diversity Committee is celebrating Black History Month by hosting an intimate panel discussion with key leaders who have been successful in the legal field. The hour-long discussion will focus on how young minorities can navigate the legal industry and position themselves as leaders in their respective communities. Diversity is critical for an organization to be able to adapt in a fast-changing environment. The panel will shed light on the challenges of attaining meaningful diversity and create discussion and generate ideas on how to continue advancing diversity within the legal industry.

Eight attorneys earn distinction in Business North Carolina's 2019 Legal Elite

1/2/2019

RALEIGH, N.C. — Poyner Spruill LLP is proud to announce that eight attorneys received a total of nine recognitions as members of Business North Carolina’s 2019 class of Legal Elite. This included Keith Johnson becoming a member of the Business North Carolina’s Legal Elite Hall of Fame for Environmental attorneys.

p.s. Lunch & Learn: How Certain Tax Changes Could Impact Your Personal Life

12/20/2018

The Tax Cuts and JOBS Act will affect divorce, estate planning, and much more. Join us to learn what you can do to mitigate the impact.

Poyner Spruill named a firm of the year winner in Lawyer Monthly Legal Awards 2018

12/13/2018

RALEIGH, N.C. — Poyner Spruill is pleased to have earned recognition in the Lawyer Monthly Legal Awards 2018 as the Administrative and Environmental Law Firm of the Year for the United States.